November 19, 2026
Through the first ten months of 2026, the median resale home in the Reynoldsburg City School District sold for $304,500, according to Columbus REALTORS. This November, two builders are advertising brand-new townhomes with Reynoldsburg addresses at prices that start just below that number. M/I Homes' Summit Crossing opens at $299,900. Ryan Homes' Wilson Ridge lists two finished homes at $289,990 and $299,990.
That changes the question a buyer at this budget is asking. The choice is no longer a new home versus an older one at different prices. The same money buys either a new attached home where someone else mows the lawn and clears the snow, or the typical resale home sold in the district this year, with its upkeep fully on the buyer. A brand-new detached house in the same school district starts about $100,000 higher.
The single-month numbers move around because Reynoldsburg is small. In October 2026, the district's median sale price was $298,000, up 14.8% from October 2025. That month had only 28 closed sales. In September 2026, the median was $325,000 on 36 sales. The year-to-date figure through October smooths that out. It covers 388 closed sales at a median of $304,500, almost flat compared with the same stretch of 2025.
So the typical Reynoldsburg resale has held near $300,000 all year, and the new townhomes were priced right at that level.
Resale supply is tight. In October 2026 the district had 72 homes for sale, or 1.8 months of supply. Across the entire Columbus REALTORS MLS that month, supply was 2.8 months and inventory was up 15.9% from a year earlier. The regional median in October was $332,250, so Reynoldsburg sits below the central Ohio price and has fewer homes to choose from. Sellers there received 96.6% of their original list price in October and 97.6% for the year through October. You can read the full monthly reports on the Columbus REALTORS October 2026 housing report page.
For a buyer at $300,000, those few dozen resale listings now compete with builder inventory priced in the same range.
The resale average in the Reynoldsburg district was $180.56 per square foot in October 2026, the same figure as October 2025. Ryan Homes' Mendelssohn at Wilson Ridge is a 1,978-square-foot townhome with three bedrooms, two and a half baths and a two-car garage, advertised at $289,990. That works out to about $147 per square foot for new construction.
The gap is roughly $34 a square foot. The resale average blends every home type sold in the district, and each sale price includes whatever land and exterior came with that home. The townhome buyer gets new mechanicals, new finishes and a smaller patch of ground. Both builders say lawn care and snow removal are included. A lower price per square foot on the townhome reflects shared walls and a smaller lot, so compare the two by what you would own and maintain.
Before you compare the two, ask how much the association dues are and which exterior items they cover. A dues payment changes the monthly comparison. Builders can provide the association documents.
Summit Crossing sits west of Summit Road, between East Main Street and Refugee Road. As the Columbus Dispatch reported, it is in the Licking County portion of the city, and the full plan calls for 280 townhomes and 384 apartments. NBC4 reported that city council approved the first two phases on July 15, 2025, covering 24 and then 58 townhomes, out of four planned phases. NBC4 also named Metro Development as the apartment builder.
M/I Homes now lists Summit Crossing as selling, with both townhome collections and quick move-in homes on its page. The River North collection is a three-level design with four build-to-order plans starting at $299,900, $312,900, $317,900 and $339,900. The Charlestown collection is two stories with two or three bedrooms and starts between $349,900 and $374,900, depending on the plan. Homes across the community run from 1,630 to 2,136 square feet and have farmhouse-style exteriors.
Price follows layout here. At Summit Crossing, the lowest starting prices are for the three-level River North plans. A buyer who wants living space on two floors instead of three pays about $50,000 more at the Charlestown starting price.
These prices also relate directly to the resale numbers. In October 2026, the median list price of new resale listings in the district was $279,950. The entry River North plan costs about $20,000 more than that, and the Charlestown plans cost about $70,000 more.
For a buyer who wants new construction and a yard, the closest option is M/I's Spring Hill Farm at 7820 Oldham Drive. Homes there start at $399,900. M/I describes it as the only community selling brand-new homes in the Reynoldsburg City School District, the same boundary the Columbus REALTORS figures above cover. The Smart Essentials collection has ranch and two-story plans from 1,440 to 2,340 square feet. The Premier collection runs from 1,756 to 2,871 square feet with up to five bedrooms. The community has ponds, walking paths and a playground.
That $399,900 starting price is about $95,000 above the district's year-to-date resale median. So at a budget near $300,000, a buyer in this district has two practical options: a new townhome or a resale home.
My background is in construction management, and it changes how I look at both options. Each one has a different weak spot to check.
On a new townhome, the risks are in workmanship. A three-level plan like River North puts more stairs and more vertical framing into a smaller footprint, so I look closely at the stairs, the floor-to-floor transitions and the shared walls between units. If you are buying build-to-order, ask the builder whether an independent inspector can walk the home before the walls are closed. A quick move-in home is already finished, so plan for a full inspection of the completed house before closing. In both cases, ask where the association's exterior responsibility ends and yours begins. Lawn care and snow removal are included, but the documents set out who handles the roof, the siding and the driveway.
On a resale house near the median, the risks are age and deferred maintenance. Ask how old the roof, furnace, air conditioner and water heater are, then price out replacements before you write an offer, because the lower purchase price can disappear into those repairs. In October 2026, sellers in the district averaged 96.6% of their original list price, and homes sold in a median of 27 days. That leaves some room to negotiate over items an inspection documents, but not much time to decide.
For more on the inspection side, our guide to what to expect from a home inspection in Columbus covers the process, and our post on new construction versus resale in Westerville compares the same choice in another suburb. You can run monthly numbers for either option with the mortgage calculator.
There are very few. The district recorded three condo sales in October 2026, down from seven in October 2025. In this market, most attached-home choices at $300,000 are new townhomes.
Yes, by this fall's figures. The district's October 2026 median of $298,000 was below the region-wide October median of $332,250. The district also had 1.8 months of supply that month, compared with 2.8 months across the MLS.
Yes. The full plan is 280 townhomes, and the first two approved phases covered 82 of them, according to NBC4.
If you're deciding between a new Reynoldsburg townhome and a resale house at the same price, Bryce G Smith can walk both with you, compare inspection findings and association documents side by side, and price the repairs before you make an offer. Schedule a free consultation, and we'll look at your options in Reynoldsburg together.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Contact Bryce today to learn more about his unique approach to real estate and how he can help you get the results you deserve.